In this week’s episode of The Bible for Normal People, Pete talks with philosopher James K. A. Smith about contemplative Christianity and how the mystical tradition can offer a different way of approaching faith, uncertainty, and the presence of God. They explore how experiences of suffering, depression, and the unraveling of old beliefs can lead people away from the need for certainty and control, and toward silence, spiritual openness, and a deeper trust in God. Together, they consider how contemplative practices invite people to move beyond rigid either-or thinking, embrace the mystery of faith, and discover the deeper truth that God is love and that we are beloved.
Mentioned in This Episode
Books:
Make Your Home in This Luminous Dark: Mysticism, Art, and the Path of Unknowing by James K. A. Smith
Into the Silent Land by Martin Laird
Interior Castle by St. Teresa of Ávila
Inspiration and Incarnation: Evangelicals and the Problem of the Old Testament by Peter Enns
New Seeds of Contemplation by Thomas Merton
Join: The Society of Normal People community
Support: www.thebiblefornormalpeople.com/give
-
Pete: [00:00:00] This is Pete Ruins Everything, where assumptions come to die and nobody leaves happy. I'm Pete Enns.
This is Pete Ruins the News. Let's talk about something that happened recently involving Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin. He was speaking at an event in Edmond, Oklahoma, when former Mayor Randel Shadid challenged him about immigration enforcement. Shadid essentially asked, "How do you reconcile your Christian faith and the teachings of Jesus with the way your agency treats people?"
And that's a good question, and also something of an accusation. You know, Mullen could certainly challenge it. He could say, "Well, you just misunderstood what happened," or, "Let me explain our practices." But instead, he insisted that Jesus taught people to obey the nation's law, and that's where my ears perked up.
Where? [00:01:00] Where does Jesus say that? I don't mean can you construct a Christian argument for respecting government authority? I'm sure you can. I mean the specific claim that Jesus taught us to obey the laws of the nation where we live. I'd like the reference, please. Preferably something a little more specific than the Bible.
Now, I can already hear it. "Pete, what about render unto Caesar? Jesus said that, right?" Well, yeah. So let's talk about Caesar. Jesus was asked whether it's lawful to pay taxes to the emperor, and this is a trap. Roman taxation is part of life under occupation. If Jesus says not to pay, well, you know what's gonna happen.
He can be accused of opposing Rome. If he says to pay, he risks sounding supportive of Rome's rule over his people. Jesus asks for a coin. "Whose image is on it?" "Caesar's." "Then give Caesar what belongs to Caesar and God what belongs to God." Christians have debated that response for centuries, but whatever else it means, it does not say that [00:02:00] everything Caesar commands is morally right.
It doesn't put Caesar's conduct beyond criticism, and it certainly doesn't tell government officials to answer questions about their treatment of people by reminding everyone that Caesar makes the laws. You have to add quite a bit to get there. A statement about paying taxes has become a blanket instruction to obey the government?
Hmm. Then that interpretation gets presented as something Jesus plainly taught? You know, we can become so familiar with our interpretation that we forget we're interpreting. But, you know, let's give Mullen's position its strongest hearing. The New Testament does contain instructions to submit to governing authorities, and it's in Romans 13.
That's the obvious example. Paul tells his readers to be subject to those authorities and describes authority as established by God and tells people to pay their taxes. That's in there. I'm not going to make it disappear because it's inconvenient. But we need to notice three things. First, that's Paul, not Jesus.
If you're [00:03:00] telling us what Jesus taught, make sure you know who said it. Second, Paul himself repeatedly ran into trouble with governing authorities because of his mission. He didn't simply stop whenever that mission met official opposition. So whatever "be subject to the governing authorities" means in Romans 13, Paul's own life complicates treating it as, "Do whatever the government tells you to do."
Third, even if Paul is telling Christians to obey the government, how does that answer a crucial question about whether the government is treating people justly? Does obey the government mean that people exercising that authority have a moral blank check? Obey the government does not mean whatever the government does is right.
Even if we grant a responsibility to obey laws, we still have to ask whether a particular law is just. We still have to ask whether the way it's enforced is just. We still [00:04:00] have to ask whether people are being treated with dignity "We're enforcing the law" might explain your authority, it doesn't establish your ethic.
You haven't answered a question about Christian ethics by telling me something is legal. You've told me it's legal, but legal can be wrong, and Christians can never be quiet about a law of the almighty state that undermines human flourishing and is just plain unjust. And the Bible gives us plenty of reasons to keep asking questions after the government and authority has spoken.
Think about the prophets. They spent a lot of time telling people with power that they're using it badly. The king doesn't get to say, "Excuse me, Amos, we have governmental authority here. We can do what we want." Amos knows they think that, hence his urgency in calling them out for injustice. The prophets ask whose interests the court serve, what happens to the poor, and who profits from the arrangement?
Having authority makes you accountable for how you use it. It's not freedom [00:05:00] from accountability. And you know what? Even within the New Testament, Romans 13 isn't the only voice. In Acts, the apostles refuse an order to stop teaching because they must obey God rather than human beings. And in the Book of Revelation, imperial power is portrayed as a beast.
Those passages don't give us permission to ignore any law we dislike, but they do prevent us from turning submission to authority into an absolute principle that's immune to moral scrutiny. We have to examine what authority is actually doing, which brings us directly to the question Mullin was asked: how are people being treated?
Even if someone has violated immigration law, their legal status doesn't answer every question about what you may do to them. What level of force is appropriate? What happens to their children? Are they receiving adequate food and medical care? What safeguards protect people from wrongful detention? [00:06:00] What happens when the government makes a mistake?
You can believe immigration laws should be enforced and still ask every one of those questions. And a government official ought to be able to answer them. And you don't have to accept every allegation against an agency to recognize that these are legitimate questions. The official can challenge an accusation with evidence, but saying, "We enforce the law," doesn't tell us whether the accusation is true or whether the conduct is defensible.
It leaves the question unanswered. Now, just to be clear, I don't think Jesus handed us a complete immigration policy. You can't open Matthew and find staffing requirements for asylum hearings. And I'm not going to pretend my preferred policies fall straight out of the Bible while everyone else is interpreting it.
I'm interpreting it, too. But Jesus does give us teachings that should shape how we treat people. Take the famous Parable of the Good Samaritan. A man asks Jesus who his neighbor is. Jesus tells a story in which a priest and a Levite, fellow Jews to, to [00:07:00] Jesus, they pass by a wounded man. But a Samaritan comes along.
Someone across a deeply rooted social and religious divide. He's the one who stops and cares for him at considerable inconvenience and expense to himself. And Jesus tells his questioner to go and do likewise. That story doesn't give us an immigration policy, but if you're going to invoke Jesus for public policy, it does put an obligation on you that you can't just sweep away.
There's a person in front of you. What do you owe them? If you have the power to detain that person, separate them from their family, or deport them, that question becomes more urgent. They are vulnerable to decisions you get to make And that brings us back again to what Mullin was asked: How do you reconcile your agency's treatment of people with the teachings of Jesus?
He can dispute the allegations. He can explain his agency's conduct, but invoking obedience to the law is not an [00:08:00] adequate or even relevant answer. If you're going to bring Jesus into a defense of your policies, you need to explain where that obligation shows up in the way you treat the people under your power.
Okay, rant over. Let's get to this episode. My guest today is James K.A. Smith. He goes by Jamie, and he is a Christian philosopher who is a professor of philosophy at Calvin University. He is a prolific writer, truly prolific writer. Just Google him. And he's written a lot on Christian beliefs and practices, and his most recent book is a game-changer, Make Your Home in This Luminous Dark: Mysticism, Art, and the Path of Unknowing.
That's a long title for a great book, and it is an amazing book. I deeply recommend it. In this book, he tells a story of how a professional philosopher who spent a career thinking about knowledge found himself needing to learn how to not know and how that is changing [00:09:00] Jamie's understanding of the faith, God, himself, and the work that he does.
So I'm very excited to have Jamie on because he both has a story that I resonate with and that many of you will resonate with as well. So let's get to it.
Jamie Smith, welcome to Pete Ruins Everything. I'm not gonna ruin you, though. You're a good guy.
James: Too late. Too late. It's really, it’s great to see you, great to be with you. Yeah. Thanks for the chance to have a conversation.
Pete: Oh, absolutely. And, and when I, um, I came across your most recent book, and you can feel free to talk about it later and just maybe let people know what's, what's, what the book is about.
But, um, I, I just, I, I, I s- saw this and I read it and I said, "Okay, I need to talk with this guy," because our stories are... There's a parallel in some respects to our stories over the past, let's [00:10:00] say, decade or two. Um, a development. Should I call it an evolution? I don't know what to call it, but it's-
James: Sure
Pete: -it's a movement and it's been life-giving, I think, for you, and it's been life-giving for me as well, and that's... I don't know, what word do we give this, Jamie? Contemplative Christianity? I just don't...
James: You know? That's been one of the options I've gone for. I- Yeah ... you know, it's, it's a mystical stream, but it's, um, yeah, contemplative spirituality, I think, is one way to get at it.
Pete: Right. Can you just talk about what, what that word means to you, contemplative?
James: Yeah. I, I mean-
Pete: Are you up on a pole someplace just not talking to your family- ... not eating for a week or-
James: Right. Right. Yeah. I mean, uh, in my heart sometimes. Uh, I, I mean, I think of contemplation in a couple of ways. One is it really is cultivating a particular form of prayer life and spiritual attention that is, [00:11:00] like, being quiet and shutting up and it's meditative. So there is, um, a suite of disciplines and practices of prayer and attention and listening that are contemplation. Um, but I think the fruit of all of that then is a contemplative Christianity which now I, what I would say is you move into a posture or a way of approaching God and thinking about divine things that, that doesn't operate on the same categories and register as, well, a lot of the Christianity that you and I were formed by.
Pete: Mm-hmm. Right.
James: So, so in that sense, think of contemplative, contemplative Christianity as a form of Christianity that manages to somehow hold things together that other streams and forms of Christianity are [00:12:00] bent on parsing.
Pete: Uh, yeah. Right, right, right, right. There's a unitive dimension to this, right?
And, um, and also, um, silence plays a role in that, right? Yeah. Yeah. How, how does it play a role in that?
James: Yes. So, I mean, in, in Make Your Home in This Luminous Dark, this new book, what I try to do, and I, I'm not the expert on this, but what I try to do is digest this kind of great heritage of contemplative practices, uh, that we learn from St. Teresa and St. John of the Cross and Cloud of Unknowing. And to me, it's kind of this movement of this four-fold path where you learn how to cultivate solitude precisely so that you can find stillness and silence. And the whole point of that is getting to a [00:13:00] new form of kind of spiritual attention and listening where you're waiting. Uh, and, and in some ways you're trying to listen for, uh, the voice of God that has been with you and present with you the whole time. It's just that the noise and chatter of everything else, including a lot of religion drowned out that voice.
Pete: Mm-hmm.
James: So you get from solitude to silence, and silence now gets you in this receptive posture this mode of, of, uh, your hands are open. That also, however, turns out to be a posture of incredible spiritual vulnerability.
Pete: Uh-huh.
James: Which is why I think the mystics universally and uniformly testify to then this experience of a kind of disruption and upending and- um, being bowled over by the dark night [00:14:00] of the soul or this cloud of unknowing, and I think that's integral to this journey. Um, that's why it resonates with a certain kind of experience of what some people maybe today call a kind of deconstruction of faith. Right. But the mystics are saying, but the whole point is to, to dwell in that disruption and de-centering and dark night to get to a new place of wonder where now you just kind of have a spiritual attunement and openness and availability that you didn't have before. So the silence piece, to me, I, and I don't know what your experience is, my... is kind of like creating the conditions of possibility for God to kind of come in and, well ruin everything.
Pete: Yeah. Yeah, right.
James: And-
Pete: God ruins everything.
James: Yeah, right. God ruins everything, and you get to a place eventually, [00:15:00] by God's grace, where you say, "Thank you."
Pete: Yeah.
James: Right. That, to me is what the mystics testify about.
Pete: Yeah. And that takes more than a hot minute.
James: Yes, exactly.
Pete: Yeah, it does.
James: Maybe, maybe this is another thing that we should say, too. I think, you know, what we're calling the contemplative tradition, some people also, we associate it with mysticism.
Pete: Mm-hmm.
James: And it's not uncommon to associate mysticism with this kind of, like, ecstatic rapture. Right, right. Do you know what I mean?
Right. Like, think of Bernini's sculpture of Saint Theresa. Yes, yes. And it's kind of like- ... I'll have what she's having. Um, but and of course that's, that can be part of it. But it's not even the goal, St. Teresa says, right? It's actually to kind of, um... It's, it's a, it's a practice. It's a journey. It is a long pilgrimage.
Pete: Mm-hmm.
James: And, um, I, I think it's not the mountaintop and it's not an achievement of an experience. It's more like [00:16:00] cultivating a way of being that sort of transforms who we are.
Pete: Right. Yeah. I, um, I'm reminded here of Martin Laird, who is... I, I don't know if he's still in Villanova.
I don't know.
James: He is.
Pete: He is? Okay.
James: He is, and a huge influence on me.
Pete: Me too. Yeah. And I, in his book, uh, Into the Silent Land, right?
James: The gem.
Pete: Um, I read it when it came out. I said, "Eh." Yeah. Three or four years later, I was like, "Oh, okay."
James: Yeah.
Pete: I'm reading it now, and I can't get through it 'cause I'm, I'm getting it, right?
Yeah. And it's the stillness. You know, we're made for contemplation, and then we die, and if we haven't figured it out yet, we'll keep figuring it out afterwards, you know? I said, I like... Like, I can live into something like that, you know? That's a vision of the Christian faith that is, um, both challenging and also, uh, I think deeply comforting, and it...
I don't know. I, I mean, we'll get to this now maybe. It releases me, um, [00:17:00] of, of needing to know everything, right? Yes. And, and that's even worse for people like you 'cause you're a philosopher. I'm just a biblical scholar. We, we're limited, but you guys, you talk about all the big stuff.
James: I get paid to know.
Pete: I know. So, tell us about that, your movement away from needing to know. And-
James: Yeah ...
Pete: maybe talk about, if you can, a little bit about that process. And I, I ask it that way because there are people watching and listening who are looking or a different way to be a Jesus person. You know?
And, and it's just not happening for them in the churches they go to and whatever, so.
James: Yeah. And I think, I think you and I share overlaps in some of our formation and experience. Um, you know, I was... I, I don't wanna go back too far, but I was a convert to the Christian faith as an 18-year-old.
Mm-hmm. And as is [00:18:00] often the case, there's a kinda zealotry that goes with that.
Pete: Sure, yeah.
James: And, um, I was also a convert through the gateway of honestly a deeply fundamentalist form of Christianity. It was the tradition that literally invented dispensationalism.
Pete: Oh, okay.
James: So these are people who love to parse and categorize and explain everything.
And so for me, being a Christian was kind of bound up with having a corner on the truth. Having an answer for everything. And the way that I was going to be faithful is by winning the arguments. And then I'd sort of discovered philosophy as a calling along the way, and these two things fed each other in now I would say rather unhealthy ways.
Pete: Mm-hmm. [00:19:00]
James: Um, and, that penchant to win the argument-
Pete: Mm-hmm ...
James: was really kind of a form of domination and control.
Pete: Yeah, yeah.
James: Do you know what I mean? I wanted... What I was, what I w- what now my 50-something self-
Pete: Mm-hmm ...
James: looks back on his younger self and is trying to be gentle with him.
Pete: Yeah.
James: And I realize, oh, you were looking for safety. You were looking for security. You were scared of something.
Pete: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
James: And, um, eventually what happens uh, the short version- ... of this story is in the middle of my 40s, a bunch of stuff hits the fan for me emotionally, psychologically, autobiographically, and all my capacity to think about stuff and figure it out and come up with the answers [00:20:00] just fail in the face of deep depression. Deep, debilitating depression. And all of a sudden, all of my intellectual acumen and all of my theological library is not...
These tools are not working. And, um, in the midst of this, this is when I started turning to the mystics.
Pete: Yeah.
James: Start reading Saint Teresa, start reading St. John of the Cross. And I, and I remember reading, uh, there's a line in Saint Teresa's Interior Castle where she says, "We need to learn to let go of our reason and our fear."
Pete: Yeah.
James: Which is such a kind of surprising conjunction of two things.
Pete: But it's deep.
James: She got it.
Pete: Yeah.
James: Yeah. In the 16th century, she got us in the 21st century. Because she's like, "You need to let go of [00:21:00] your reason and your fear," because actually both of them are compelling you, I'm feeling this directly at myself, compelling me to try to control the world in order to quell anxiety.
Pete: Yes. Yeah. Yeah. Right.
James: And, and, um-
Pete: Can I ask, anxiety about what? What do you think that's about?
James: Yeah.
Pete: I have a theory, but I'm, I'm-
James: I wanna hear it.
Pete: No, I'm gonna wait. I wanted you to say 'cause it's, it's, um, I haven't thought about it enough to call it a theory, but I will say what I think it might be.
James: I mean, I think in my case, um-
There, there were sort of some deep wounds and losses and absences in my life.
Pete: Okay.
James: And I think part of control was trying to paper over the fact that that had made me, um, had made me feel unsafe in the world. So all that
Pete: [00:22:00] chaos, uh, the control helped ease that emotional chaos.
James: Yes. But it is not a sustainable endeavor.
Pete: It's not.
James: No. It's not a sustainable endeavor. It's tiring. And, when you added a kind of theological impetus to it, I dare say, again, I'm trying to be gentle with my younger self. I do think he was doing the best he could. Yeah. But I would say now looking back, there was really a kind of idolatrous-
Pete: Mm-hmm
James: penchant about it. Because it's almost like I was trying to be the god in this scenario who's in control of everything and trying to manage it, and to be able to explain it to myself in ways that were safe and secure and orthodox or whatever that might be. And I, I just found, um, it was the unsustainability of that endeavor that didn't, it didn't work. It just simply didn't work. And it also started, [00:23:00] I realize it started to yield both a version of God and a version of me that I did not like very much. That I did not think looked like a Jesus follower.
Pete: Yeah.
James: But what- Wow ... but I mean, what's your experience of that or account of-
Pete: Well, I mean, my, uh, y- you know, all rooted in different experiences, right?
Yeah. So for me, um- I think the control comes from a fear of, as specific as this might sound, we wanna have a good handle on what happens to us after we die.
James: Mm.
Pete: And we wanna figure this stuff out. And if we don't, then, you know, I'm not sure. And, uh, I think for me growing, you know, I'm, I'm...
I have a couple years on you. I'm in mid-60s now. And, uh, but, but it lo- ironically mid-40s was the same time it began hitting me. It's that mid-life time when you have a choice [00:24:00] to just keep playing the game or to crash and burn and start over again, in a sense. And you didn't have much of a choice there.
Neither did I, actually. The way it came about me, I didn't... I, I, I, I just, there was no other way to go. Yeah. There was no other way to stay Christian than by letting go of the stuff that I had learned. And, you know, when I, um... I mean, you know my story. You know, I left Westminster in whatever year it was. 2008. Yeah. And for six months I was the happiest person on earth, because I was away from this stuff. It was a lot of pressure being there. And, um, didn't wanna be told what to believe, and I wanna think, figure stuff out. Well, be careful what you wish for, 'cause after about six months I didn't have any guardrails anymore.
James: Oh. Yeah.
Pete: I didn't have that confessional context. Oh. And, and so I, um, I began wondering, well, uh, actually I sort of heard a little voice inside me say, "All right, Pete, you got what you [00:25:00] wanted. Now what do you believe?" And I said, "I don't have the slightest idea." Whoa. And it was, like, for a year like that.
And, and just mourning the loss of faith. And, and, um, but I think, you know, not to speak for you, but that was a grace for me.
James: Yep.
Pete: Um, and I had to move into that darker place or else... Was I depressed? Um, I was anxious, I was depressed, uh, I was... I just didn't have energy. And, um, what got me thinking differently was a video I saw online about-
James: Really?
Pete: Well, this was about, um, John Kavanaugh. Mm. Moral philosopher, uh, St. Louis University.
James: Okay.
Pete: Uh, he went to visit Mother Teresa in the '70s, 'cause he was having his own crisis of faith, and he said, "I'll just take my sabbatical with her. She'll know what to do." Right? And so he shows up, and, "Hi, how are you?
And what can I do for you?" And he goes, "You can pray for me." And she, uh, [00:26:00] and, uh, she goes, you know, "What would you like me to pray for?" And he goes, "Pray that I have clarity." And she said, "I will not pray for that."
James: Mm.
Pete: Mm. "Well, why not?" "Because clarity is the last thing you're holding onto and must let go of." And that hit me like a two-by-four in the back of the head.
But then he said, "Well, you seem to have tons of clarity." And she laughed. She says, "I've never had clarity a day in my life, but I've had trust, so I will pray that you trust." And for me, the book The Sin of Certainty came out of that way- of thinking. And it changed everything. I really sat there and I said...
And I had to learn to be gentle with my younger self, too, and I am. But I thought, "I've been doing this wrong," through no fault of my own necessarily. And plus, you know, James, both of us... I just called you James, sorry. Jamie, um, you answer to both. I think, and I don't wanna be, uh, this is not unnecessarily [00:27:00] critical, but the Calvinist context is a highly intellectual world.
Yes. They have all the bases are covered. They have the bases on top of the bases, on top of the bases.
James: Oh my gosh.
Pete: I think it's the most intellectually robust Christian tradition in the Protestant world. Yeah, that's my belief. Uh, just in terms of what they do.
But that doesn't help you here.
James: There's a shadow side to this.
Pete: There's a shadow side to that, exactly. And, there you have it. So.
James: No, no, exact- And, and I mean, you, you and I both have experience in different ways. I wholly agree with your theory, by the way. There is something about the strange gift of this contemplative mystical tradition, is you actually realize that uncertainty is not a threat.
It is not an enemy. It is not something to be vanquished.
Pete: Yeah.
James: It is the condition of finitude and [00:28:00] being a creature. And the question is, um, can you get to a place where you dwell in uncertainty as a country to inhabit rather than, uh, a threat to be escaped? Right. And, and I, that's what I have k- and but in order to do that, you have to get to this place where, this is Martin Laird, too- The discursive analytic toolkit of mind that, and philosophers, you know, we literally are sharpening those tools all day long.
Pete: Right.
James: You have to quiet that impulse, that penchant, that drive to carve up, categorize, conceptualize, and compartmentalize because that does not work [00:29:00] when you're dealing with the infinite.
Pete: Right.
James: And, and so you have to kinda let all of that go, not for ignorance.
Pete: Mm-hmm.
James: Uh, unless it's what Augustine calls learned ignorance. There... I love that idea, this notion of a learned ignorance.
Pete: Mm-hmm.
James: Where, oh no, now you realize there's a kind of way of being attuned and aware that is, it's really non-binary thinking.
Yeah. Like you, somehow you're able to hold together things that the discursive analytic mind is saying, "No, it's gotta be either this or that." And to go back to Calvinists are very good at this. It's either this or that, right? And you, uh-
Pete: It's either Rome or Geneva.
James: -scholasticism is very good at this, right?
Yeah. Yes, right. It's either this or that. Uh, it's either us or them.
Pete: Yeah.
James: And, and the mystics are like, "This or that? Yes."
Pete: Yeah.
James: And, some of our friends are gonna listen [00:30:00] to this and they're like, "Oh my gosh, these guys have kissed their brains goodbye. This is wishy-wash."
But I'm not bothered by this at all-
Pete: Yeah, no, not at all
James: ... because they think we're lapsing back into something sophomoric, when I think what we've tasted is something beyond this binary way of thinking.
Pete: Right.
James: And, yet it is, it is not... And, and I would say the irony is, you know-
I'm almost hesitant to use this word because it's so loaded in the Calvinist tradition, but I have a kind of assurance of my being beloved that has been completely unavailable to me in any prior incarnation of my journey.
Pete: Well, of course. I mean, who cares about your emotions and your experiences?
It's just whether you have the proper [00:31:00] theological... I mean, that's a little reductionistic, but in my experience it's not really that far from the truth either, you know? And to poo-poo this kind, this is a very experiential, I would say subjective undertaking. Yep. And some would say, and I'm one of them, welcome to life.
Life is subjective. Yes. Yeah. I mean, we try to control it and categorize it.
James: Yeah, yeah.
Pete: And, you know, when I'm hearing you speak, Jamie, um, you know, one thing that I've discovered over the years is how deeply this notion is baked into the Christian tradition, I'm gonna say since Paul.
You know, I, I think, you know, Colossians and Ephesians are very, I think, mystical kinds of texts, the kinds of things that they say. And, and I know, you know, a lot of people, um, will say that Paul probably didn't write those, and that may very well be right. And if, if he did write it, it's [00:32:00] probably in the end of his life or something where he's not too concerned about the fights he used to have.
He's just giving you this cosmic vision of things. Or if it is somebody else, I hope, I actually hope Paul didn't write them 'cause then his followers took Paul to the next level.
James: Yeah. And it shows you. It's getting into the stream of the tradition.
Pete: Yes, exactly, and that's something that I've just, you know, I'm grateful that I've picked up these voices from the past who all say, "You cannot exhaust this with your words or with your thinking. It doesn't work that way." Yeah, yeah. And, you know, uh, Cyril of Jerusalem, I think, um, around the fourth century, I think it was, but he's a catechism he was teaching and he's telling these people, you know, his catechesis, and he was telling them, "You know, we can't really understand this God we're talking about."
And that's Christianity 101. That's not something you have to wait until your 40s or 50s to figure out. That's presented to you in this orthodox, in the best sense of the word orthodox, in [00:33:00] this orthodox tradition. And I remember in, you know, in my seminary years, I never once heard of this ever. That you cannot capture God with your words. Yeah. I heard the opposite. It's our obligation. You can't have mystery. The mysteries are to be solved, not to be lived into, right? And-
James: Exactly ...
Pete: and I think, okay, that's, that's nice until you think, unless, until you have certain experiences, right?
Yep. Like you did and like I did and then you just say, it's a wake-up call and you start thinking not so much about I mean, I had to stop thinking pretty, I don't know about you, I had to stop thinking pretty quickly about a God up there. I never really believed that 'cause it doesn't make much sense, but I had to really own it.
So it's not up there looking down, making cameo appearances. You know, the invocation before a something, "Oh, Lord, come into our presence." And now I'm like he's here. Are you kidding me? He's, he's in through [00:34:00] everything and it's such an attractive way of embodying the Christian faith.
It's particularly because I don't have to worry about figuring it out. I just learn and live and be kind and try to set aside time to be thankful for what I have and for who I am.
James: Yeah. And, and I think that's part of the You know, this contemplative stream, this mystical tradition is in many ways for me a set of disciplined practices of letting go.
Uh, uh, you know, which is, which is l- opening up... You know, we have this penchant to, like, grasp and control and manage. And it's just kinda like, no, let it go. Let it go. Uh, Meister Eckhart is so brilliant on all of this stuff. And, and [00:35:00] the letting go is also then letting go of a deep-seeded hubris, to imagine, "I've gotta figure this out." Yeah. "I, I'm supposed to tell everybody the way it is." There's a certain sense in which you are actually granting, you know, if we still wanna just tweak the noses of the Calvinist tradition, you're actually granting more sovereignty to God.
Pete: Yeah.
James: Because it's not something that could be managed by our imagination.
Pete: Right, right.
James: I mean, I would say, I think it's worth talking about a little bit that I totally agree that, uh, in some ways this mystical tradition... And it's very interesting, by the way, that folks like St. Teresa, St. John of the Cross, um, these are folks who are kind of contemporaries of the reformers, if you start to think, right?
That's right, they were. Yep. It's very, very interesting. 1500s are a hot spot, and [00:36:00] part of what's going on here is a new and deeper discovery of interiority. Do you know what I mean? Of, of what we're calling subjectivity. And, and in some ways it is Christianity in this stream, and I think Augustine's Confessions are like a harbinger of what's to come as well, and maybe as you're saying, Paul is, too. This deepening of a sense that the person has this intimacy and interiority and subjectivity that is almost its own cosmos. I think we shouldn't, uh, um... Th- this is why I think you can read the mystics and they feel unbelievably contemporary in many ways.
Right. Because they get the subjectivity and almost the self-consciousness that comes with subjectivity that we experience so pensively.
James: But the other thing that just constantly strikes me about the mystics, especially if you read, [00:37:00] like, St. Teresa or The Cloud of Unknowing, which is actually a little earlier- It is the case that these folks are all embedded in communities.
Pete: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
James: Do you know what I mean? So here's another case. We don't have to pick between subjectivity and communality.
Pete: Mm-hmm.
James: Right. Right? It is, it is our embeddedness in communities of practice that grant us the recognition to also become these deep wells of subjectivity and interiority. And so I think the other thing that I find, um, just of note is that on the one hand, the mystics are pursuing these contemplative practices, and they're constantly getting in trouble with the authorities, right? Because they just, they're talking on registers that don't fit what the doctrinal police are parsing. So they're always getting in trouble. Eckhart's always getting in trouble. On the other hand, [00:38:00] they are praying the divine office seven times a day. They're celebrating the Eucharist. They are still giving themselves over to these embodied, communal, incarnate practices, which to me is another form of trust. Mm-hmm. Do you know what I mean? You're, you're kind of entrusting yourself to a community, and that's something that I guess has also been important for all the ways that the church drives me freaking crazy. Um, on like- ... next level. I also know that I don't wanna be a lone ranger.
Pete: Yeah, of course. Yeah.
James: And I don't want, you know, kind of free market, uh, franchised Christianity, and there's something about the mystics also still grant us a kind of Catholicity that's capacious.
Pete: Mm-hmm.
James: Uh, and that, that has been, I [00:39:00] think, another sort of gift. In learning how to live with the uncertainty, right?
Right. It's like, well, I don't have to figure this out because also we are a we.
Pete: In terms of, again, the Reform tradition, which we're both-
James: Intimately familiar.
Pete: Yeah, we are familiar with it. And, you know, part of me being gentle with myself is looking back and seeing the things that I learned that are actually still helpful and that I still sort of say to my students, but sort of filtered a little bit differently.
There are good things there. But I think what... I'm not sure which, which is the chicken and which is the egg here, but the role of the Bible encourages that kind of control because it's there in black and white, and you say, "Well, [00:40:00] I'm not sure these two stories can really be reconciled." Well, they have to be reconciled or else the Bible can't function the way we need it to.
And part of my... I mean, I've never really thought about it deliberately until years ago when this stuff started happening. That may be behind the energy of me critiquing, for lack of a better word, uh, hopefully kindly and generously, but still critiquing Biblicism, you know? Yes. And certainly inerrancy.
And because it simply... Scripture doesn't get in the way. No. How we understand it and what we lay over it and the philosophical trappings we put over it, that can get in the way, and I think it regularly does.
James: I mean, I think you've been working on this since way back inspiration incarnation at least.
As you say, somebody might say, "Well, wait, how do I put this together with the way I read the Bible?"
Pete: Uh-huh.
James: You can't. Because the way you read the Bible is a problem.
Pete: [00:41:00] Yeah.
James: And, and, uh, it's not the Bible, it's the hermeneutics that are brought to it. And, and of course what, what frustrates me to no end is the extent to which some, uh, Protestant evangelicals do not realize the utter novelty and modernity of their hermeneutical frames.
Pete: Mm-hmm.
James: And so you're right, you don't... This is, this is, um, when you journey with the mystics, you get the Bible back in all of its kind of mystagogical wonder.
Pete: Yes, exactly. Right, right.
James: And I, I will also say, you know, I did, um, our pastors were on sabbatical this past summer and, you know, they were scraping the bottom of the barrel because I did, like, halftime preaching.
Pete: Yeah.
James: And it was actually such a joy to return to the Bible now in this posture- and to try to preach in this way and say, [00:42:00] "I'm not here to didactically dissect." Right. It's, uh, you know, the author's intent in this text. Yeah. I, I think that is just a way to gut the Bible of what it actually is. It's more like what is the wonder that, that God is inviting us into in this story? And including sometimes, what does God wanna blow up for us?
Pete: Right.
James: You know, like, what is this thing? I do think contemplative spirituality is not about confirmation bias because it's actually cultivating a way that we get exposed to this, this upending. There's, I don't know if you are a fan of Jason Isbell, singer-songwriter Jason Isbell, but he has a line that goes, um, "You thought God was an architect. Now you know he's something like a pipe bomb ready to blow. [00:43:00] Everything you built that's all for show goes up in flames."
Pete: A, a loving pipe bomb.
James: It is. It's exactly... It's, it's... God is saying, "I am going to come and blow up your house of cards so that you know you are loved."
Pete: It's a wrathful, a regenerative kind of wrath, right? It's not-
James: I don't even think he's angry. I think God is saying, um- You confused your little card castle with the kingdom.
Pete: Mm-hmm. So I'm gonna help you out here.
James: Let's blow, let's blow it up ... we're going to deconstruct that and, and invite you to something else.
Pete: Right. And I think, you know, you mentioned deconstruction a couple times, and it... I, I, I do. I am saddened by how much negative press that idea gets, even though sometimes I think it's for good reason.
I think [00:44:00] when people say they're deconstructing, they're saying, "I just don't believe this stuff anymore." That's not deconstruction. I think deconstructing is something that happens to you. I think you were deconstructed because of life circumstances. So was I, and I knew I couldn't c- that road came to an end very quickly.
James: Yeah.
Pete: And I didn't like it. It was quite- Yeah ... terrifying, actually. Yes. And it was, it was... It made me very, very sad for about a year, right?
James: Yeah. Yeah.
Pete: And I didn't know what to do, but that's... That is, that's... Deconstruction happens to you, I think.
James: Yeah.
Pete: And then you say, "Okay, well, what do I believe next?" And even if you say, "I have no idea," you're on the path to reconstruction or reorientation, as Richard Rohr says.
James: Yeah.
Pete: And, and I, I think sometimes, uh, the whole process can get almost cheapened when evangelicals talk about it. And I, that sounds very harsh, but I'm gonna. stick with that. And, not all the time, but sometimes ...
James: I, like you, I generally try to cultivate, um, [00:45:00] a, a charitable posture towards folks who maybe use that term or are on that kind of journey.
Pete: Right.
James: But I... A- and, and, you know, like, look, I teach undergraduates. And inevitably, I have the conversation with the college sophomore who comes in sheepish, a little nervous, but they... You know, she tells me, "I don't think I believe in God anymore."
Pete: Mm-hmm.
James: And I, I'm just always trying to be a non-anxious presence in that space, and then we... I ask her a bit more about, "Okay, tell me a bit more about the God that you don't believe in anymore."
Pete: Right. Right.
James: And it is always a God well lost. You know? Like, I don't believe in that God either.
Pete: Right.
James: And just so you know, that doesn't mean you're not a Christian.
Right. Like, so we can start from there. But I do think with you, I worry a little bit about sometimes folks who take on this mantle of identity of [00:46:00] deconstruction, but in my reading, they are actually still locked in the binary.
Pete: Yes.
James: Still thinking on this kind of discursive analytic. Right. And, and what they've decided is they're swapping one pole of the binary and swinging to the other pole of the binary.
That, that to me is not- I mean, maybe that's... I don't know what deconstruction is, but to me that's not what I'm interested in.
Pete: Right. Right.
James: Um, I'm interested in what does it look like to get to a spiritual posture and relationship with God and a walk with Jesus where I'm not locked in this shuttling between two binaries I'm invited into just a completely different category of reception.
Pete: I think that word invitation is something that people would benefit from to think along those lines, that what if God is inviting you into, um, an awareness of the divine presence around us and in us. I think I'm sort of a panentheist.
Are, are you... Is that okay?
James: I don't know if contractually I'm [00:47:00] able to admit the same thing.
Pete: Yeah, I can. I can.
James: But the fact is, look Jonathan Edwards was pretty much there, so it can't be all bad. That's gonna be my appeal. If the president calls, I'm like, I think a little bit like Jonathan Edwards does.
But no-
Pete: Well, my rudimentary understanding of the history of Christian thought, I'd say I think there were a lot of panentheists throughout the history of the Christian faith. I sometimes wonder about Paul, too, but anyway.
James: Yes. Mostly because classical theism is a utter modernist invention that is locked into these categories. I mean, maybe especially for some of your folks who are listening too who, you know, maybe this is kind of rattling things for them and, and I guess I would also want to encourage people to, by admitting that as you said, this is a journey. Yeah. It takes time.
Pete: Mm-hmm.
James: And I don't know what your experience was like, but for long periods and seasons, [00:48:00] um, this journey felt like abandonment.
Pete: Yeah, sure.
James: Right? And, and, and I just want people to not, like, so if you feel that way, do not be frightened because Saint Teresa admits the same thing. Saint John of the Cross admit- Saint Teresa of Calcutta admits the same thing. Right. This is something that struck me so much in Thomas Merton's New Seeds of Contemplation. He would constantly talk about this aridity, this arid desert that he found himself in. And you, you would think that that is the very opposite of a vibrant spiritual relationship, but actually it's an experience of being stripped of all artificial measures in order to then finally discover something else. There's a line in New Seeds of [00:49:00] Contemplation where Merton says something like, "Prayer and love are learned in the moment when prayer is impossible and your heart turns to stone." And I remember reading that and thinking, "That's me." And yet the desire to pray and love was a signal of a reverberating grace that's still at work there. So um, maybe we just need to share more stories with one another about experiences of absence and even what feels like abandonment that are part of a growing Christian life.
Pete: Well, that'd be great.
James: Right? Because that itself would give a lot of people permission to feel like, "Oh, [00:50:00] I'm not leaving."
Pete: Mm-hmm.
James: Uh, I feel left, but this is not the end of the story.
Pete: Right. And, um, that's the very thing you're not allowed to do in what's called a control, a, a control paradigm of the Christian faith.
Oh, I like that. You're not allowed to do that. That's good. Yes ... that's unfortunate, but that's the truth and again, I say that gently, 'cause I don't, I mean, they're just not there, so to speak. And, you know, pastors are trained and they learn things and this is how it is, and, they're being faithful in their own mind, and I understand that, and that's why I don't, I don't look down on it.
But I say, "If that's it, I'm an atheist."
James: Yep. Yeah.
Pete: If that's what this is about I want nothing to do with this Christian faith. Yeah. I want something that is, um, going to really, well, transform me. Yeah. And, and like you've been, you know? Yep. Yeah. [00:51:00] And like we're in the process of that.
James: My wife has a theory here, which I just want to honor because I think, could I just float the possibility that there might be common gendered experiences of this where white dudes like you and me who are basically trained to imagine we're in control of the world. Right? Do you know what I mean?
Like, I'm, I'm just so... This is the way socialization works.
Pete: We’re trained to mansplain God to God.
James: And, and so for us what has to happen for us to be cracked open is a deep de-centering and humbling and, you know, this, this breaking experience where like I can't figure this out. We lose control, and then we realize we weren't supposed to have control.
Pete: Mm-hmm.
James: Deanna keeps saying, "You know, there are a lot of people in the world who've never had any [00:52:00] illusions of being in control."
Pete: Right. Exactly .
James: "And in fact, they have been controlled." What does the contemplative tradition mean for them? And I, I think it's a really, really good question.
Pete: Right.
James: I don't think everybody's template here is going to be the same. And I think some folks are gonna have to go through this kind of cracking open experience. Others who maybe their predominant experience in religious Christian spaces has been being controlled. Um, their experience might be actually a liberation and an empowerment, where they realize, "Oh, wait, I am free to speak. I am free to say." "I am free..." I, I, I have, I haven't worked this all out, but I, I do think there's something important about that.
Pete: I think I agree with that. It echoes a little bit, I recall Richard Rohr saying that, um, I [00:53:00] forgot what book it is, but, um, being drawn into this happens typically one of two ways: through pain or through love.
And at first read that, I said, "There's nothing love about this for me." Yeah. "I just got my ass kicked."
James: Yeah.
Pete: You know, but other people, you know they're different, you know? Yes. And, and they come at it maybe much more gently and more of like just entering a stream.
James: Yeah.
Pete: And we spend most of our time trying to paddle the wrong way up the river to get out of the way. And, and all of a sudden the canoe breaks. You can't help it. You're just, you're swept down the river.
James: Yeah.
Pete: And not a gentle river. Yep. You hit some rocks along the way. Yeah. But that has to happen sometimes. And, um, and that's nothing to brag about. That's, that's, that's the way it is for some people, and others have a very different journey. But the end point-
James: It's the vagaries of our biographies, and I, I think you're right. That sounds very wise and suggestive because, right, other people, what they might... They, they probably still have to let [00:54:00] go of some conceptual boxes they have God in. But it's precisely so that they've experienced it as belonging.
Pete: Yes.
James: And-
Pete: Right ...
James: All of it is about getting to belovedness for me in the contemplatives. It's always realizing that the deepest truth of oneself and the fire that ignites the cosmos is that God is love and I am beloved. We are beloved. And for somebody who has felt marginalized or manipulated or controlled they are also being invited to discover that, but they don't have to go through all the shit that we did. It's rather just kind of like welcome.
Pete: Yes, exactly.
James: Welcome. Right. Yeah. Embrace. Uh, and you, and you want that for everyone.
Pete: It's, you know, again, people like us, you know, culturally, educationally, racially, right?
We're- you know, white privilege is a thing.
James: Yeah.
Pete: And male white privilege is [00:55:00] a thing ... is, is a big, big thing. But, you know sort of like the people who are up here they need to be crushed.
James: Yep. Yes.
Pete: And the people down here, they need to be elevated and lifted up.
James: Oh. And I think... Boy, this sounds like the gospel almost ...
Pete: almost. And, but I think... And that's what God does. And I look back at my experience. I'm grateful for that pain, that sense of abandonment. I had to do that.
James: Yes. Same.
Pete: As nice of a guy as I was, I had to go through that or else...
I think my greatest fear is not that I'd stop believing anything. My greatest fear is that I would become an old man and still think along those lines. And people like that become grumpy.
James: Yeah.
Pete: Yeah, exactly. I don't wanna be a grumpy old man.
James: No, exactly. Exactly.
Pete: Well, James, there are about 40 other questions I want to ask you.
We're gonna have to do this another time.
James: Yeah, this is great. I would be totally game to join you again. I appreciate the sincerity and vulnerability. Um, and, uh, it's great to have a space to just be able to be ourselves.
Pete: Right. Yeah, and I feel the same way, and thanks for writing that book too.
James: My pleasure. Great chat with you. Thank you.
Pete: See ya.
Pete: And now it's time for You Ask, Pete Answers
Anonymous Narrator: If God appeared to Pete and offered to answer one question about the scriptures, clear up one textual corruption, one interpretive disagreement, the actual history behind a particular Bible story, what question would Pete ask?
Pete: Hey, Gregory, I appreciate this question because it makes me think about what I'm most curious about and what I might once have wanted answered that doesn't seem quite so pressing anymore to me.
So anyway, I probably wouldn't use my one question, that you've granted me, [00:57:00] uh, to clear up some textual problem in the Bible. Some might, but that doesn't really interest me that much. Uh, those are legitimate scholarly questions, but I don't think Christianity's hanging by a thread somewhere waiting for us to figure out the meaning of a disputed Greek or Hebrew word or phrase.
Uh, I might be tempted also to ask about Adam and Eve. Um, I think that story is mythical rather than historical, but that doesn't mean I don't have questions about these stories. Like why in this story put a forbidden tree in the garden in the first place? And what's with this talking serpent, and why was nobody warned about him?
And, um, why is knowing good and evil a problem when everywhere else in the Bible, it's a good thing? It's what you strive after. That's what the law is about. That's what Proverbs are about. And I wouldn't ask that, though. And I wouldn't ask who wrote the Pentateuch or the pastoral letters, as much as I would like to know that.
If I really had just one question to ask God, I think I'd ask something historical. And oddly enough, it wouldn't be whether [00:58:00] Jesus rose from the dead or whether David actually existed or even if the virgin birth were true. Here's what I would ask. What exactly happened that gave rise to Israel's Exodus story?
That's the question. Did something happen? And if so, what happened? And is it anything like how the Bible describes it? Was there, say, a historical event that sort of kickstarted an Exodus tradition Or maybe is it a story created out of whole cloth to give Israel an identity? Or maybe some combination of these two?
You know, I, I find these questions fascinating for two reasons. Actually, more than just fascinating, important for two reasons. First, the Exodus is one of the most, if not the most important story in the entire Bible because it's the foundation of Israel's understanding of itself and of its God and indeed of its very existence.
You know, we were enslaved in [00:59:00] Egypt, God heard our cries and delivered us, gave us laws and land, and here we are. And that sequence, that rhythm runs through the Hebrew Bible. It even announces the Ten Commandments, right? They start, "I am Yahweh, your God, who brought you out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of slavery."
That's how it begins, and then it launches into the laws. First, you establish what God did in the Exodus, and then you go into the laws. And it's not simply a story about something God did long ago. In, in the Hebrew Bible, it becomes a reason for how Israelites are supposed to treat each other, especially the vulnerable.
You know, remember that you were slaves in Egypt, so don't treat others harshly. The story shapes Israel's identity, its theology, its ethics, and again, its very existence. But here's the thing, folks. For all its central importance, the Exodus story is one of the most historically difficult stories in the Bible to verify.
We've learned [01:00:00] an enormous amount about ancient Egypt and the emergence of Israel, but we still haven't learned all that much, and we certainly can't confidently say what, if anything, happened to inspire the biblical account of the Exodus story And I would really like to know. Now, I wouldn't ask God simply, you know, "Did the Exodus happen, yes or no?"
It's a yes- it's like I'm in Congress. It's a yes or no question, just answer it. That's too blunt and too boring, and doesn't really get at it. What exactly would count as the Exodus happening? So did it happen, yes or no? Yeah, but what do you mean happened? What happened? Like every detail in the Biblical account happened?
Did all the plagues happen? Did the plagues happen? The, the huge numbers that are there, the crossing of the sea when it split in half, the 40 years in the wilderness. Or maybe there was some historical experience that inspired an exaggerated story that we read about in the Book of [01:01:00] Exodus. Maybe a smaller group escaped from Egypt, and over time, their small experience became the shared story of Israel, and that's one theory.
Maybe several different experiences contributed to that story. Or maybe something happened that none of our current theories has come close to imagining. You know, how does an event from the past become a memory, and how does that memory become a tradition, and how does that tradition become a story that shapes generations of people who weren't there?
Think about it. You know, whatever happened or, or didn't happen behind the Exodus story, it became central to how an entire people understood who they were and who their God was. And I don't know the answer to those questions, and that's precisely why I'd like to ask God about it. I'd love to know. And yes, knowing the answer could affect how I understand the theology of the Book of Exodus.
I don't think history and theology [01:02:00] are completely separate things. I think they mesh together. The story makes claims about God acting in the world, and knowing more about that history behind those claims could change how we think about it. But knowing what happened wouldn't answer every question. We'd still have to ask how the story was told and retold, why certain features became important, and what later generations made out of it.
Knowing the history wouldn't eliminate interpretation, in other words. It would actually give us much more to interpret. So Gregory, that's my nerdy answer. I'd ask God what actually happened that gave rise to Israel's Exodus story. Not because I think knowing the answer would settle every question about the Bible or Christian faith, not at all.
But because it's a foundational story, its history is extraordinarily difficult to recover, and I've spent a good portion of my life thinking about it, and I would really like to know [01:03:00] All right, folks. Well, that's it for this episode of Pete Ruins Everything, and we hope to see you back here next time.
Jared: All right, one last thing. If you made it this far, you're clearly the kind of person who thinks about this stuff more than is probably necessary.
Pete: We say that with love, but you're not alone. We are also those people.
Jared: Community for us folks who do a lot of extra thinking, it's called The Society of Normal People, which, yes, we know is a little ironic given what we just said.
But it's a good group, smart and weird in the right ways, and not trying to convince anyone of anything.
Pete: Come be weird with us. The link is in the show notes, or go to thebiblefornormalpeople.com.
Jared: Front slash join. I forgot to put that.